Who Leads the List? Top 10 Most Penalty Saves by a Goalkeeper in ISL

When spot‑kicks decide matches, fans inevitably ask, “Who has the most penalty saves by a goalkeeper in ISL?” The answer carries all the drama of a last‑minute penalty: Albino Gomes leads the charts with eight spot‑kick stops. 

Each saved penalty shifts momentum, turns goalkeepers into heroes, and fuels conversations about who is the most penalty saves goalkeeper in ISL. 

These aren’t just shot‑stoppers; they’re mind‑readers, cat‑quick athletes and, sometimes, match‑winners. By delving into the numbers and stories behind every ISL most penalty saves goalkeeper, this article reveals why chasing the record for most penalty saves by a goalkeeper in ISL has become a badge of honour.

Top 10 Goalkeepers With The Most Penalty Saves By A Goalkeeper In ISL

There is domination of Albino Gomes with eight stops, though others such as Mohammad Nawaz, Rehenesh and Gurpreet make the competition exciting. (1)

Breaking Down The Numbers And Stories

Each penalty saved tells a story, numbers only scratch the surface of the drama and instinct behind these feats.

Albino Gomes – The “Penalty King”

Albino’s legend began in 2020–21 when he became the first keeper to save three penalties in an ISL season. In that campaign he stopped spot‑kicks against NorthEast United, Chennaiyin FC and Bengaluru FC. 

He added another in 2017–18 while at Delhi Dynamos. Returning with Jamshedpur FC in 2024–25, he saved four more penalties. His success rate, 50 %, reflects both sharp reflexes and the ability to read minds. 

He is often introduced as “the most penalty saves by a goalkeeper in ISL” hero.

When he transferred to Jamshedpur in 2024, he once more silenced the critics when he made several stops that won matches. Every save contributes to the legend about the man whose glove is a nightmare penalty.

SUGGESTED READ: After  22 Years, Mohun Bagan Wins IFA Shield 

Mohammad Nawaz – Agility Meets Composure

Quick and agile, Nawaz’s penalty-saving reputation stems from a standout moment when he denied Sunil Chhetri for FC Goa. He has saved four penalties in total, two for Mumbai City FC, one for FC Goa and one for Chennaiyin FC. 

While he isn’t yet the ISL most penalty saves goalkeeper, his penalty save rate of 26.7 % shows he could one day challenge the record for the most penalty saves by a goalkeeper in ISL. 

TP Rehenesh – Calmness Under Pressure

Known for his calm presence, Rehenesh has saved four of 16 penalties faced, giving him a penalty save rate of 25 % success rate. Three of those saves came during his stint with Jamshedpur FC, while the fourth was recorded for Mumbai City FC. 

Although he doesn’t hold the title of most penalty saves goalkeeper in ISL, his consistency keeps him in the conversation about who is the most penalty saves goalkeeper in ISL.

Gurpreet Singh Sandhu – Towering Reliability

Bengaluru FC’s No. 1 has four ISL penalty saves: two in 2019-20 and one each in 2017-18 and 2022-23. His 1.97 m frame, calm authority and long reach make him extremely hard to beat. 

With four saves, he sits just behind the leader in the most penalty saves by a goalkeeper in ISL rankings, reminding fans who is the most penalty saves goalkeeper in ISL.

Edel Bete – Early ISL Heroics

The Armenian-French keeper became an ISL legend by leading ATK FC to the title in 2014 and helping Chennaiyin FC lift the Cup in 2015. He saved two penalties during Chennaiyin’s 2015 campaign and another in 2016 for FC Pune City. 

His penalty save rate of 50 % success rate is the highest among keepers with three saves, placing him firmly among the top most penalty saves goalkeeper in ISL rankings.

Mirshad Michu – Rising Reliability

Part of NorthEast United FC and East Bengal FC, Mirshad has three ISL penalty saves and an impressive success penalty save rate of 42.9 %. While he isn’t yet the most penalty saves goalkeeper in ISL, his efficiency signals potential to challenge for that title in future.

Karanjit Singh – Veteran Composure

The Chennaiyin FC stalwart is best remembered for a pivotal save against Kerala Blasters in the 2017-18 season, when he waited until the last moment to deny Courage Pekuson. With three penalty saves and a 27.3 % success rate, Karanjit’s experience keeps him on the list of most penalty saves by a goalkeeper in ISL, even if he’s not the record holder.

Kamaljit Singh – Athletic Shot-Stopper

Known for his athleticism, Kamaljit has stopped three spot kicks, though his 16.7 % success rate shows how unforgiving penalties can be. His tally places him among the group of keepers noted for the most penalty saves by a goalkeeper in ISL, and he could yet improve his standing (2). 

Laxmikant Kattimani – Final-Night Hero

Despite a modest penalty save rate of 15.8 %, Kattimani etched his name into ISL folklore by saving three penalties in the 2022 final. In that shoot-out he denied Mark Leskovic, Nishu Kumar and Jeakson Singh, securing Hyderabad FC’s maiden title. 

Those three saves ensure he features on the list of ISL most penalty saves goalkeepers even though he isn’t the outright leader.

Vishal Kaith – The Clean-Sheet King

Vishal has three penalty saves to his name and a 13 % success rate, putting him within the broader most penalty saves by a goalkeeper in ISL conversation. Yet his bigger claim to fame is a league-record 15 clean sheets in the 2024-25 season, underscoring that success as a goalkeeper isn’t only about penalties.

Amit Mishra’s Thoughts

The stories behind the most penalty saves by a goalkeeper in ISL are as gripping as any match. The top of the list is occupied by Albino Gomes who has eight saves and a 50 percent success rate however there are also challengers such as Mohammad Nawaz and TP Rehenesh who are promising a great future.

Likewise, these goalkeepers remind us that football isn’t just about scoring, sometimes, the moment that decides a season is a gloved hand pushing a ball wide. As fans, we live for these moments and the human drama they bring.

Visit JeetWin Sports to stay updated with all things football!

FAQs

Reference

 (1)– indiansuperleague

(2)– timesofindia.indiatimes